Article

Wind farm turbines wear sooner than expected, says study

The analysis of almost 3,000 onshore wind turbines — the biggest study of its kind —warns that they will continue to generate electricity effectively for just 12 to 15 years. The wind energy industry and the Government base all their calculations on turbines enjoying a lifespan of 20 to 25 years.

The analysis of almost 3,000 onshore wind turbines — the biggest study of its kind —warns that they will continue to generate electricity effectively for just 12 to 15 years.

The wind energy industry and the Government base all their calculations on turbines enjoying a lifespan of 20 to 25 years.

The study estimates that routine wear and tear will more than double the cost of electricity being produced by wind farms in the next decade.

Older turbines will need to be replaced more quickly than the industry estimates while many more will need to be built onshore if the Government is to meet renewable energy targets by 2020.

The extra cost is likely to be passed on to households, which already pay about 1 billion a year in a consumer subsidy that is added to electricity bills.

The report concludes that a wind turbine will typically generate more than twice as much electricity in its first year than when it is 15 years old.

The report’s author, Prof Gordon Hughes, an economist at Edinburgh University and a former energy adviser to the World Bank, discovered that the “load factor” — the efficiency rating of a turbine based on the percentage... more [truncated due to possible copyright]  

The analysis of almost 3,000 onshore wind turbines — the biggest study of its kind —warns that they will continue to generate electricity effectively for just 12 to 15 years.

The wind energy industry and the Government base all their calculations on turbines enjoying a lifespan of 20 to 25 years.

The study estimates that routine wear and tear will more than double the cost of electricity being produced by wind farms in the next decade.

Older turbines will need to be replaced more quickly than the industry estimates while many more will need to be built onshore if the Government is to meet renewable energy targets by 2020.

The extra cost is likely to be passed on to households, which already pay about £1 billion a year in a consumer subsidy that is added to electricity bills.

The report concludes that a wind turbine will typically generate more than twice as much electricity in its first year than when it is 15 years old.

The report’s author, Prof Gordon Hughes, an economist at Edinburgh University and a former energy adviser to the World Bank, discovered that the “load factor” — the efficiency rating of a turbine based on the percentage of electricity it actually produces compared with its theoretical maximum — is reduced from 24 per cent in the first 12 months of operation to just 11 per cent after 15 years.

The decline in the output of offshore wind farms, based on a study of Danish wind farms, appears even more dramatic. The load factor for turbines built on platforms in the sea is reduced from 39 per cent to 15 per cent after 10 years.

Prof Hughes said in his conclusion: “Adjusted for age and wind availability, the overall performance of wind farms in the UK has deteriorated markedly since the beginning of the century.

“In addition, larger wind farms have systematically worse performance than smaller wind farms.”

The study also looked at onshore turbines in Denmark and discovered that their decline was much less dramatic even though its wind farms tended to be older.

Prof Hughes said that may be due to Danish turbines being smaller than British ones and possibly better maintained.

He said: “I strongly believe the bigger turbines are proving more difficult to manage and more likely to interfere with one another.

"British turbines have got bigger and wind farms have got bigger and they are creating turbulence which puts more stress on them.

"It is this stress that causes the breakdowns and maintenance requirements that is underlying the problem in performance that I have been seeing.”

Prof Hughes examined the output of 282 wind farms —about 3,000 turbines in total — in the UK and a further 823 onshore wind farms and 30 offshore wind farms in Denmark.

The report, published last week by the Renewable Energy Foundation (REF), a think tank that has campaigned against wind farms, will give ammunition to sceptics, especially within the Conservative Party, who believe the cost of subsidies to the wind industry is far too high and that the growing number of turbines are blighting the countryside.

Dr John Constable, the director of REF, said: “This study confirms suspicions that decades of generous subsidies to the wind industry have failed to encourage the innovation needed to make the sector competitive.

“Bluntly, wind turbines onshore and offshore still cost too much and wear out far too quickly to offer the developing world a realistic alternative to coal.”

Prof Hughes said his analysis had uncovered a “hidden” truth that was not even known to the industry. His report was sent to an independent statistician at University College London who confirmed its findings.

The report has been disputed by the wind farm industry. It points out that the consumer subsidy is paid only when turbines produce electricity, meaning there is a strong incentive for wind farms to be properly maintained to protect them from wear and tear.

Dr Gordon Edge, dthe irector of policy at RenewableUK, the body that represents Britain’s wind farm industry, said: “Wind farm developers only earn money for the clean electricity they actually generate, so it’s very much in their interests to make sure that their turbines are maintained… to an optimum level, which includes upgrading as the technology improves.

“Better turbines are being developed all the time, so it’s absurd to focus purely on the past as this report does, and pretend that that’s the way things are going to be in the future.”

Wind Power
News »
UK News »
Earth News »
Renewable Energy »
Environment »
In Wind Power
Wind brings 24hr power to remote Scottish island
Wind brings 24hr power to remote island
Wind farm
How noisy is a wind farm?
More than 195,000 wind turbines to appear outside homes by 2020: The Burbo Bank Wind Farm, Liverpool 
Wind turbines would need to cover Wales to supply a sixth of country's energy needs
Environmental benefit of wind farms: overstated   
Wind farm benefits 'overstated'
Floating wind farms to be developed as part of government-backed research 
Floating wind farms to be developed as part of government-backed research
Paid content
 Security Systems for your Home. Search And Get Protected
Security Systems for your Home. Search And Get…
Home Security | Sponsored Listings
 Size Matters! Tips for Keeping Your Breasts Healthy
Size Matters! Tips for Keeping Your Breasts…
HealthCentral
 Hysterical Beach Photos You Can’t Unsee
Hysterical Beach Photos You Can’t Unsee
giveitlove
 The Most Beautiful Woodstock 1969 Photos Ever Captured
The Most Beautiful Woodstock 1969 Photos…
Definition
 [Gallery] The Last Photos Of The Romanov Family Have Resurfaced
[Gallery] The Last Photos Of The Romanov Family Have…
Direct Expose
 Vermont Will Pay You to Install Solar if You Live Near Whitingham
Vermont Will Pay You to Install Solar if You Live…
Energy Bill Cruncher
 (Photos) This Image Has Not Been Edited, Look Closer
(Photos) This Image Has Not Been Edited, Look Closer
HistoryInOrbit.com
 Use This Simple Trick To Protect Your Computer For Free
Use This Simple Trick To Protect Your Computer…
The Review Experts
 [Photos] Guy Posts Selfie With His Dog. Police See it And Rush To His Home.
[Photos] Guy Posts Selfie With His Dog. Police See it…
Bob's Hideout
Recommended by
Top News Galleries

Latest Video»
Rat climbs over man
Large rat climbs on sleeping commuter

Disabled great-grandfather denied stairlift and forced to crawl
Old and frail wombat is rescued
Elderly wombat rescued after being attacked
Scientist in lab 
Sponsored
When media meets medicine
More From The Web

 

More From The Web

Paid content
 Over 65? It is Time For A Dental Insurance Plan. Search For Insurance Policy
Over 65? It is Time For A Dental Insurance Plan. Search For Insurance…
(mydental-insurance.com)
  A Brave Photographer Smuggled These 28 Photos Out Of North Korea
A Brave Photographer Smuggled These 28 Photos Out Of North Korea
(Definition)
 [Pics] They Reached The Bottom Of The Deepest Cave On Earth, And What They Found Could Not Be Explained
[Pics] They Reached The Bottom Of The Deepest Cave On Earth, And What…
(Science 101)
  [Photos] Millions Are Grieving Over Jonathan Scott’s Tragic Loss, And It Will Have You In Tears
[Photos] Millions Are Grieving Over Jonathan Scott’s Tragic Loss, And…
(Direct Expose)
Recommended by
WORLD NEWS
 Progress 17 supply vehicle departs from the International Space Station
The latest world news
View
US NEWS
 Barack Obama warns American dream is in danger of becoming a 'myth'
Latest and breaking stories from the United States
View
FILM
 
All the latest film trailers, reviews and features
View
FOOTBALL
 
Catch up on all the latest football news and results
View
Back to top

HOME
News
UK News
Politics
Long Reads
Wikileaks
Jobs
World News
Europe
USA
China
Royal Family News
Celebrity news
Dating
Finance
Education
Defence
Weird News
Editor's Choice
Financial Services
Pictures
Video
Matt
Alex
Comment
Blogs
Crossword
Contact us
Privacy and Cookies
Advertising
Fantasy Football
Tickets
Announcements
Reader Prints
Follow Us
Apps
Epaper
Expat
Promotions
Subscriber
Syndication
© Copyright of Telegraph Media Group Limited 2018Terms and Conditions Today's NewsArchiveStyle BookWeather Forecast


Source: https://www.telegraph.co.uk...

DEC 30 2018
http://www.windaction.org/posts/49258-wind-farm-turbines-wear-sooner-than-expected-says-study
back to top