Library filed under Energy Policy from Massachusetts
"It's a one-sided report," said Virginia Irvine of Brimfield, a town where a proposed wind farm caused great controversy. Neil Andersen lives near a wind turbine in Falmouth and says he is upset with the findings. "I got to the first page saying that my problems, my health problems, don't exist."
"From the time we first became aware of the bill in 2009, we were up against the Statehouse leaders, the media, and the ‘green' groups," said Eleanor Tillinghast, a member of Green Berkshires. "It was quite a fight. From the Cape to the Berkshires, we all pitched in to protest this unprecedented and dangerous piece of legislation. And to their great credit, our legislative leaders listened and reversed course on the bill."
In making his decision, Downing said he had considered what he heard from constituents and state officials during 15 hours of hearings on the bill held in Hancock and Barnstable. The siting bill has been fought by those opposed to putting wind energy projects near residential areas.
"The senate president supports local control and is not in favor of the bill," Schroeder wrote in an email to the Times. "The Senate plans to review other bills pending before the Legislature that address the costs of energy and our renewable energy goals." Opponents of the siting bill praised Murray's change of heart.
Keisch said wind turbines on ridges would be "devastating to property values" in the county, would cause utility rates to go "up instead of down," and are not a reliable source of energy. "You say that they should be part of the mix, but I think until we really understand the scientific basis for it, there are other alternatives," Keisch said.
Mr. DiMasi, off to jail this week, is the third successive Massachusetts Speaker of the House to be indicted and convicted for financial impropriety. He ought to have been charged with poorly thought out energy generation legislation. The boondoggle that is Cape Wind is a DiMasi/Patrick legacy.
The MTC, which now operates as part of the Massachusetts Clean Energy Center, takes renewable energy taxes from our electric bills and develops sloppy, poorly defined turbine project proposals. And we are forced to pay again to protect our homes from their incompetence. ...We have lost our democratic rights and have become second-class citizens, facing the theft of our land through regulation.
The state is late to the party when it comes to setting rules for wind energy development, too late to bother many Cape Codders told a state's joint committee on telecommunications, utilities and energy Thursday morning at Barnstable High.
The doctrine of the Dormant Commerce Clause prohibits a state from engaging in actions that discriminate against out-of-state business and prevents states from engaging in protectionism in which an advantage is given to in-state industries at the expense of out-of-state competitors, the brief says.
In the filing, they responded to Cape Wind, which has said the combined utility should have to buy half its power to get the deal approved. "The Department has no authority under (state law), or any other statutory provision to impose a requirement to enter into a long-term contract for renewable power," the utilities argued.
Nothing has caused more divisive and bitter controversy on Cape Cod in the past decade than Cape Wind's proposal to place 130 commercial-scale, 440-foot-high wind turbines in 25 square miles of federal waters in Nantucket Sound, just five miles off Cape Cod's coast.
The law would reduce opportunities for residents to participate in the permitting process and eliminate certain rights of appeal available to municipalities, said Eleanor Tillinghast, board member of Wind Wise~Massachusetts from the Berkshires. ...because appeals of the state siting board's decisions go directly to the Supreme Judicial Court, it would be more difficult to reverse a decision.
The proposal, which went before the state Legislature's Joint Committee on Telecommunications, Utilities and Energy last week, would establish local boards to handle wind turbine proposals as a whole instead of requiring developers to seek various approvals from multiple local committees.
Only absolute necessity, only an absence of viable alternatives, could ever justify the degradation of our mountains, and I am confident that if people take the time to study the situation, they will conclude that many less destructive and more productive and dependable alternatives are available.
The Wind Siting Reform Act is similar in many ways to a bill that nearly made it to the governor's desk during the last legislative session. That bill was passed by both the state Senate and House, but did not gain final approval before time ran out on the 2010 session.
Massachusetts lawmakers are set to consider proposal Wednesday that would establish wind energy permitting boards in communities with considerable wind resources.
Most of the conversation and legal paperwork on the deal that would create a $17.5 billion electric company has revolved around rates and consumer protection. Regulators and utility executives don't care to talk in public about another key factor: Cape Wind - and one of the private offshore project's biggest fans, Governor Deval Patrick.
State officials have made some progress with expanding our renewable energy resources in the past few years, to be sure. But the growth has been much slower than most advocates expected. However, there's another environmentally-friendly option.
"The utility sector is in the early stages of a relatively significant and long-term capital spend - a huge part of that will be environmental compliance,'' said Jim Owen, spokesman for the Edison Electric Institute, a utility trade group in Washington. "Obviously, a larger, more well-capitalized company that is [doing business] in several states is just going to have a bigger voice in the conversation.''
While the proposed regulations do not impact permitting or ban the development of biomass energy in Massachusetts, they do set a high bar for qualifying to earn RECs under the state's RPS, the DOER says.