logo
Article

Whale strandings fuel controversy: Are offshore wind farms to blame?

SAN|Shannon Longworth|Sep 23, 2023
New JerseyNew YorkOffshore WindWhales

Before constructing offshore wind farms, developers employ geophysical surveys to map the seafloor and geological layers beneath it using sound waves. Concerned communities are becoming more suspicious that geophysical surveys play a role in these whale deaths. “They’ve been doing all this work,” said Bonnie Brady, executive director of the Long Island Fishing Association. “And about the time that the work started is when the whales started piling up.”


Whales have been washing up lifeless in a startling and now-common sight along the Eastern Seaboard, a cause for concern for local communities. Various residents and conservationists are pointing fingers at offshore wind farm surveys conducted as a precursor to building wind energy facilities in the Atlantic Ocean.

“It’s very moving in a bad way to see that,” said Cindy Zipf, executive director of Clean Ocean Action in Long Branch, New Jersey. “Something that’s so majestic and so beautiful – just kind of lifeless on land.”

Clean Ocean Action is one of several organizations along the Jersey Shore that publicly expressed concern regarding the “scale, scope, and speed” of offshore wind energy development. 

Before constructing offshore wind …

... more [truncated due to possible copyright]

Whales have been washing up lifeless in a startling and now-common sight along the Eastern Seaboard, a cause for concern for local communities. Various residents and conservationists are pointing fingers at offshore wind farm surveys conducted as a precursor to building wind energy facilities in the Atlantic Ocean.

“It’s very moving in a bad way to see that,” said Cindy Zipf, executive director of Clean Ocean Action in Long Branch, New Jersey. “Something that’s so majestic and so beautiful – just kind of lifeless on land.”

Clean Ocean Action is one of several organizations along the Jersey Shore that publicly expressed concern regarding the “scale, scope, and speed” of offshore wind energy development. 

Before constructing offshore wind farms, developers employ geophysical surveys to map the seafloor and geological layers beneath it using sound waves. Concerned communities are becoming more suspicious that geophysical surveys play a role in these whale deaths.

“They’ve been doing all this work,” said Bonnie Brady, executive director of the Long Island Fishing Association. “And about the time that the work started is when the whales started piling up.”

The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) has classified the humpback whale strandings since 2016 and the minke and North Atlantic right whale strandings since 2017 as “Unusual Mortality Events” (UMEs). This designation highlights the significant and unexpected number of whale strandings, which have happened as survey work picked up in the Atlantic.

“In this region, we did call for a pause – a halt – to any activity, so we could determine whether or not the unprecedented amount of pre-construction activity may have had something to do with this incredibly devastating spike in whale and dolphin deaths that occurred,” Zipf said.

While developers have done surveys for more than a decade, several survey projects began in the Northeast around when whale strandings started to climb in 2016.

That year, US Wind performed surveys near Maryland, and DONG Energy –now Orsted – worked off the coast of Massachusetts into the following year. In 2017, Ocean Wind and Deepwater Wind conducted surveys off the coast of New Jersey and New York.

Critics have not alleged that the survey sounds directly kill whales. Instead, they have speculated that the sounds disrupt whale behavior, making them more prone to ship collisions and mortal entanglements. NOAA Fisheries states that “no scientific evidence” supports the claim that noise from offshore wind surveys could potentially cause whale mortality. Instead, the agency attributes the increased whale strandings to climate change.

“Our climate is changing, and one of those key changes is the warming of our oceans,” NOAA Fisheries states on its website. “In response, many marine species are adapting by moving into new areas where conditions are now more favorable.”

NOAA Fisheries explains that whales could be following prey closer to shore, putting them at higher risk of vessel strikes or entanglement, which would make offshore wind projects the solution to the whale problem rather than the cause.

The issue has become overtly partisan in national discourse. Those who Straight Arrow News interviewed have been accused of being pawns for the fossil fuel industry and “right-wing,” regardless of their actual political leanings.

“When people bring that up to me, it just indicates that they’re just unable or unwilling to talk about the substance of the problems,” said Bob Stern, president of Save LBI. “I don’t believe the media has done a good job.”

Stern added that he thinks the press coverage has been lopsided in favor of offshore wind and should more thoroughly evaluate the purpose of these projects.

The final environmental impact statement for Vineyard Wind 1 states that offshore wind projects would have “no collective impact on global warming.” But they “may beneficially contribute to a broader combination of actions.”

Vineyard Wind declined an interview, but when questioned about the multi-billion-dollar project’s lack of impact on global warming, replied: “Once completed, the Vineyard Wind project will show that we can responsibly build clean energy projects that move us forward in the fight against climate change.” 

“I think neither party is really addressing this problem of climate change and sea level rise well,” Stern said. “I think you have a number of people in one party who are denying the problem. And then you have the number of people in the other party, saying they can solve the problem with some wind turbines. Neither is accurate. And neither, frankly, is useful.”

Straight Arrow News spoke with Darlene Ketten, a marine biologist and neuroanatomist at the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institute, to learn more about how sound affects whales. Ketten specializes in underwater hearing and mechanisms of hearing loss. 

“There’s no evidence that hearing has had a role in those ship strikes,” Ketten said. “I’m not saying that it didn’t. But to the best of my knowledge, there hasn’t been an extensive examination, or any kind of procedures to determine if the animals that are being hit by ships have hearing deficits.”

According to Ketten, performing a necropsy on a dead whale has many challenges. Not all hearing loss is visible post-mortem; the whale could be too decomposed when it gets to shore, and cutting a whale’s ear out is difficult. In truth, responders aren’t required to collect information on hearing damage.

There is not enough information to evaluate whether hearing loss has played an indirect part in whale deaths. However, the current activity by offshore developers can disturb marine mammals. 

Developers seek incidental harassment authorizations from NOAA to conduct activities that can disturb marine life.

“The degree of disturbance is the question,” Ketten said. “It’s likely that they would leave the area, leaving the area could be an important problem. If they leave the area and it turns out that’s where their major source of food is…then we’ve disturbed their ability to forage to feed. And that can also happen for breeding habitats, etc.”

They wouldn’t apply for incidental harassment authorizations if they didn’t think their work could affect marine life.

Documents for the Atlantic Shores project state that the sounds from survey work have the potential for “Level B harassment.” According to NOAA Fisheries, “Level B harassment includes actions that could disturb, but not injure or kill, a marine mammal by disrupting behavioral patterns, including migration, breathing, nursing, breeding, feeding, or sheltering.” Level B harassment can also include a “temporary hearing threshold shift” (temporary hearing loss).

During construction, the authorizations allow for Level A harassment, which includes permanent hearing threshold shift. More projects are nearing the construction phase. 

During construction, the “pile-driving” phase emits sound. Giant piles are hammered into the ocean floor to secure turbine foundations, producing underwater noise. Because this sound can disrupt marine life, the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM) requires that developers use various mitigation tactics. For example, observers monitor the areas under construction for the presence of marine mammals.

While BOEM declined a request for an interview, Erica Staaterman, the deputy director of BOEM’s Center for Marine Acoustics, provided a statement.

“We only allow construction to occur during windows of time when key species are least likely to be present in the area, and we require noise abatement methods to be deployed around the foundations to minimize the amount of acoustic energy that is emitted into the water,” Staaterman said.

However, mitigation tactics aren’t perfect. The “bubble curtain” technology developers use to dampen the sounds from pile driving doesn’t work for lower frequencies, which baleen whales can hear. 

Once turbines are installed, they capture and transmit energy from the wind. During multiple decades of a wind farm’s life, the underwater sounds from this phase will be constant.

According to Save LBI’s calculations, the Atlantic Shores project will create noise levels exceeding 130dB in the migration corridor of the endangered North Atlantic right whale, a stark contrast to NOAA’s threshold for behavioral harassment, which is 120dB. Concerns abound that these high sound levels could interfere with whale migration, posing further risks to their survival.

The construction of wind farms continues, and more ocean areas are being leased for future development despite ongoing research efforts funded by the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management to investigate the population effects of offshore wind development on North Atlantic right whales.

Critics argue that the rush to build offshore wind farms may disregard the potential consequences for marine life. While there is no proof that offshore wind development has contributed to the whale strandings. The government and the media discredit reasonable concerns from offshore communities about the issue. Stern, Brady, and Zipf remain determined to seek answers.


Source:https://san.com/cc/mysterious…

Share this post
Follow Us
RSS:XMLAtomJSON
Donate
Donate
Stay Updated

We respect your privacy and never share your contact information. | LEGAL NOTICES

Contact Us

WindAction.org
Lisa Linowes, Executive Director
phone: 603.838.6588

Email contact

General Copyright Statement: Most of the sourced material posted to WindAction.org is posted according to the Fair Use doctrine of copyright law for non-commercial news reporting, education and discussion purposes. Some articles we only show excerpts, and provide links to the original published material. Any article will be removed by request from copyright owner, please send takedown requests to: info@windaction.org

© 2026 INDUSTRIAL WIND ACTION GROUP CORP. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
WEBSITE GENEROUSLY DONATED BY PARKERHILL TECHNOLOGY CORPORATION