Article

Velocity rises in wind-power debate

The Columbus Dispatch|Dan Gearino |September 25, 2013

Ohio Sen. Bill Seitz, R-Cincinnati, is about to release a wide-ranging energy proposal altering renewable-energy requirements. He hopes the General Assembly will pass the bill this year. ...If there is no requirement that utilities buy from within the state, then developers might pull back on projects that are in the planning stages, said a lobbyist for the group.

Both sides digging in over bill to change Ohio renewable-energy requirements

Ohio has made a strong start in establishing a "green" economy, but leaders in the wind-energy industry say that future investment in such technologies would be jeopardized if the state eliminates a rule requiring utilities to buy a certain amount of in-state renewable energy.

The comments before an industry conference yesterday came just as Ohio Sen. Bill Seitz, R-Cincinnati, is about to release a wide-ranging energy proposal altering renewable-energy requirements. He hopes the General Assembly will pass the bill this year.

"You're getting energy in Ohio, and you're getting investment in Ohio," said Rob Gramlich, senior vice president of public …

... more [truncated due to possible copyright]

Both sides digging in over bill to change Ohio renewable-energy requirements

"You're getting energy in Ohio, and you're getting investment in Ohio," said Rob Gramlich, senior vice president of public policy for the American Wind Energy Association. He and his group support keeping the requirements for purchase of Ohio-generated renewable energy.

His trade group held a conference Downtown yesterday. The event also drew protesters who say that wind energy is too expensive and overly dependent on government aid.

Ohio manufacturers are among the leading suppliers to the wind-energy industry, with 60 factories, the group said. In addition, Ohio has several utility-scale wind farms, the largest of which is Blue Creek Wind Farm in Van Wert County, with capacity of 350 megawatts.

"The policies that the Ohio General Assembly have put in place are working," said Eric Thumma, director of institutional relations for Iberdrola Renewables, the owner of Blue Creek.

He is referring to Senate Bill 221, which Seitz's bill would change. Enacted in 2008, the law says that by 2025, utilities must get 25 percent of their electricity from renewable or advanced sources and must reduce customers' electricity use by 22 percent with energy-efficiency upgrades.

Seitz's bill would leave the 2025 benchmarks intact but change several other provisions.

Among them, he would do away with the stipulation that half of the required renewable energy come from in-state sources. He has said this is because of concerns that the in-state requirement is an unconstitutional limit on interstate commerce.

Wind industry officials said there is no good reason to remove the in-state requirement. They noted that several other states have similar rules that have not faced challenges in court, and there has been no legal challenge in Ohio.

If there is no requirement that utilities buy from within the state, then developers might pull back on projects that are in the planning stages, said a lobbyist for the group. This includes seven projects that have been approved by the Ohio Power Siting Board but have not yet begun construction.

Several dozen critics of wind energy picketed outside the hotel where the conference was being held. The protest was organized by Interstate Informed Citizens Coalition, a Michigan-based group that opposes wind power.

"The overriding message is that wind electricity, contrary to popular belief, is not a replacement for fossil-fuel electricity," said protester Tom Stacy, 50, who lives near Zanesfield in Logan County. "Our tax dollars end up paying so that Americans have higher electricity costs and be less competitive in the global economy. That's insane."

dgearino@dispatch.com

@dispatchenergy

Add to Favorites
Print Story

Email
Comments
Login or register to post a comment.
flag

Thomas Stacy (ThomasStacy)

Actually I said something more like this: "The overriding message is that even though wind electricity can reduce a small amount of fossil fuel consumption, it cannot, due to its very low guaranteed continuous performance during peak electricity demand periods, replace any of the fossil fired plants which consume that fuel. This means wind electricity needs to compete with the cost of the fuel it saves - not with the cost of electricity from conventional sources, which includes the cost of the conventional plants themselves. Since that can never happen, wind necessarily makes Ohio and the US less competitive, costing far more jobs than the narrow wind manufacturing sector could ever hope to create. Using our tax dollars to support such a folly is insane." - Tom Stacy

2013-09-25 07:59:31.0

Ads by Yahoo!
Transportation Software

Transportation and Logistics software including accounting

(omni-info.com)
Cheap

Cheap Heating Parts

(www.wogsupply.com)
Web 2.0 Apps in Minutes

Generate database & reporting apps straight from your database! Try it

(www.ironspeed.com)
Towing Computer Software

Payment Plans, Free Demo

(www.TowManager.com)
AdChoices

Advertisement
•
Place an ad

News Video More Videos

Where we live: East ColumbusWhere we live: East Columbus
Artist brings 'Light' to conservatoryArtist brings 'Light' to conservatory
Westerville Crew at home on Hoover ReservoirWesterville Crew at home on Hoover Reservoir
Soccer as a second languageSoccer as a second language
Script Ohio in BrailleScript Ohio in Braille
11-year-old directs musical in Mount Vernon11-year-old directs musical in Mount Vernon
Incredible Hulk now a special deputyIncredible Hulk now a special deputy
Suspect's car found in hit-skip deathSuspect's car found in hit-skip death
Biggest Fans: Buck-I-GuyBiggest Fans: Buck-I-Guy
Matthew Cordle blacked out; remembers littleMatthew Cordle blacked out; remembers little
Development growing around Columbus CommonsDevelopment growing around Columbus Commons
St. Charles expands athletic facilitiesSt. Charles expands athletic facilities
Jack Hanna: 'I do it for the zoo'Jack Hanna: 'I do it for the zoo'
Playing football a victory for boyPlaying football a victory for boy
Soldier-dad returns home to surprise childrenSoldier-dad returns home to surprise children
Inside a Mormon food pantryInside a Mormon food pantry

Velocity rises in wind-power debate

The Columbus Dispatch|Dan Gearino |September 25, 2013

Follow Us

Donate

Stay Updated

Contact Us