Article

Elmwood turbine may be near end of life

The wind turbine constructed in 1996 by Traverse City Light & Power on M-72 in Elmwood Township hasn't worked properly for over four months. The turbine initially broke down Aug. 28. It took four months to find and obtain a replacement part at a cost of almost $38,000.

TCL&P windmill only works at half capacity after repairs

TRAVERSE CITY - The state's oldest commercial, utility-owned windmill is showing its age.

The wind turbine constructed in 1996 by Traverse City Light & Power on M-72 in Elmwood Township hasn't worked properly for over four months. The turbine initially broke down Aug. 28. It took four months to find and obtain a replacement part at a cost of almost $38,000.

Workers installed the new part on Jan. 4, and two days later it broke down again.

Utility workers had it running on Jan. 8, but the turbine currently only works at about half capacity, said Tim Arends, Light & Power's interim executive director.

"It's nearing the end of its useful life, or it may already be there," Arends said.

The turbine's 160-foot high tower with a blade diameter of 144 feet stands less than half as tall as modern turbines designed to catch Michigan's best winds. Its generator is considered inefficient by today's standards.

It was considered a big deal in 1996, said utility board Chairman Pat McGuire. At that time it was the largest operating wind turbine in the country.

It can produce about 600,000 kilowatt hours of... more [truncated due to possible copyright]  

TCL&P windmill only works at half capacity after repairs
 
TRAVERSE CITY - The state's oldest commercial, utility-owned windmill is showing its age.

The wind turbine constructed in 1996 by Traverse City Light & Power on M-72 in Elmwood Township hasn't worked properly for over four months. The turbine initially broke down Aug. 28. It took four months to find and obtain a replacement part at a cost of almost $38,000.

Workers installed the new part on Jan. 4, and two days later it broke down again.

Utility workers had it running on Jan. 8, but the turbine currently only works at about half capacity, said Tim Arends, Light & Power's interim executive director.

"It's nearing the end of its useful life, or it may already be there," Arends said.

The turbine's 160-foot high tower with a blade diameter of 144 feet stands less than half as tall as modern turbines designed to catch Michigan's best winds. Its generator is considered inefficient by today's standards.

It was considered a big deal in 1996, said utility board Chairman Pat McGuire. At that time it was the largest operating wind turbine in the country.

It can produce about 600,000 kilowatt hours of electricity a year, enough power for about 110 homes.

The turbine cost $785,000 to construct, but hasn't paid for itself and likely never will during its useful life, Arends said.

And it appears the turbine doesn't have much of a future, McGuire said.

"This particular wind turbine is obsolete and at some point you have to give up the ghost and let it go," McGuire said. "It's like an old car. At some point you have to make the decision you can no longer afford to make repairs because when you do something else goes wrong."

Arends predicted the turbine would take two years to generate enough income to cover the cost of the latest part replacement if it operated at full output with low maintenance. Now he is waiting for a contractor to determine if the newest problem is due to the new part or if the generator is breaking down.

"If it's the generator, that's a major cost to the unit," he said.

Late last year Arends assigned Light & Power staff to consider options for the wind turbine.

"Does a more modern wind turbine replacement makes sense, or is it better not having one at all," he said.

Utility officials also will try to learn if they can salvage the turbine's towers and blades and try to retrofit a new high-efficiency generator to the tower, as well as explore the cost to tear it all down, Arends said.

The utility doesn't have the expertise to answer those questions in-house, so officials will work with experts in the field to explore alternatives. Arends hopes to have a report to the board by April or May.

Until then, the goal is to keep it operating at the lowest cost possible, he said.


ShareThis Facebook Tweet LinkedIn Email Text Only

Watch where you park this winter

Many motorists ignorant of ordinance prohibiting parking on county roads
Continued ...

Jan 13, 2013 7:14 am 1 Photo
Progress Village aims to change perceptions of the poor

The vast majority of northern Michigan poor are good, hard-working people who toil at multiple jobs, many of them low-paying. The poor often are buried under layers of other complex social problems.
Continued ...

Jan 13, 2013 7:14 am 1 Photo
Man battles rare cancer

Jeff Peplinski was healthy just four months ago, a young man who looked forward to a new job and raising his toddler daughter with his fiance.
Continued ...

Jan 13, 2013 7:14 am 1 Photo
Permit extended for coal plant project construction

A coalition of Michigan electric utilities that includes Cherryland Electric Cooperative received a permit extension for the construction of a contested coal plant project, but utility officials are not saying if they intend to follow through with construction.
Continued ...

Jan 13, 2013 7:14 am
TC teen killed in crash after stealing cab

An 18-year-old Traverse City man died after he apparently crashed a stolen taxi cab.
Continued ...

Jan 13, 2013 7:14 am
Saturday, January 12, 2013
Traverse City teen killed after stealing cab

An 18-year-old Traverse City man died after he apparently crashed a stolen taxi cab early today.
Continued ...

Jan 12, 2013 10:51 am
Munson tackles obesity epidemic

Munson Medical Center aims to scale down the obesity epidemic by working with area employers, schools, health care providers and its own 4,000-plus workers.
Continued ...

Jan 12, 2013 7:14 am 1 Photo
In Body and Soul: Man loses 100 pounds

Steve Hanna, a Grand Traverse County employee, lost 100 pounds last year and he thanks the county's insurer, Blue Cross/Blue Shield, which paid for a four-month weight loss program.
Continued ...

Jan 12, 2013 7:14 am
Food on stove sparked Kalkaska fire

Food simmering on a stove sparked the fire that destroyed a 101-year-old farm house.
Continued ...

Jan 12, 2013 7:14 am 1 Photo
Friday, January 11, 2013
Equipment failure blamed for Traverse City power outage

Employees at Wendy's Hamburgers on Division Street played Frisbee in the parking lot while waiting for the power to return.
Continued ...

Jan 11, 2013 7:00 pm
Region sees increasing number of influenza cases

If you don't have the flu yet, get a vaccine.
Continued ...

Jan 11, 2013 6:28 pm 1 Photo
NMC starts new program to create jobs

Darrell Rogers was in Central Lake this week on an educational road show of sorts, training a classroom of "lean champions" at Armor Express.
Continued ...

Jan 11, 2013 7:14 am 1 Photo
TCAPS to audit marketing

A Houston-based public relations consultant will evaluate Traverse City Area Public Schools' marketing and communications department next month.
Continued ...

Jan 11, 2013 7:14 am 1 Photo
Woman posed as friend to avoid ticket

A Leelanau County woman faces a criminal charge after she posed as her friend during a traffic stop.
Continued ...

Jan 11, 2013 7:14 am
Thursday, January 10, 2013
Pure Mich. ad touts state's new right-to-work law

Critics contend a $144,000 Pure Michigan ad that touts the state's new right-to-work law poured salt in a not-so-pure wound.
Continued ...

Updated Jan 10, 2013 11:53 pm
Season snowfall totals down

Mark Zumbaugh remembers when northern Michigan snowfall patterns allowed for snowmobiling during hunting season.
Continued ...

Jan 10, 2013 7:14 am 1 Photo
Grand Traverse deputy takes plea deal

A Grand Traverse sheriff's deputy had a domestic violence charge dismissed as part of a plea deal.
Continued ...

Jan 10, 2013 7:14 am 1 Photo
Traverse City debate team on top

Traverse City Central High School arguably fielded the best overall debate team in Michigan this year.
Continued ...

Jan 10, 2013 7:14 am 1 Photo
Clearing the Record: 01/10/2013

An item in Sunday's bestsellers list cited the incorrect author for the book, "I Could Pee on This: And Other Poems by Cats." The correct author is Francesco Marciuliano.
Continued ...

Jan 10, 2013 7:14 am
Wednesday, January 9, 2013
Utility willing to help hotels save on bills

Traverse City Light & Power may provide a jolt worth $232,000 to its hotel and motel customers to help them reduce their electric bills.
Continued ...

Jan 9, 2013 6:33 pm
NMC harbor project moving ahead

Northwestern Michigan College is a step closer to its long-held plan to build a deeper, bigger harbor for its educational and research vessels.
Continued ...

Jan 9, 2013 7:14 am 4 Photos
Traverse City Opera House show benefits WRC

Producers of the first "Miriam Pico Picnic at the Opera" variety show didn't need their "applause" sign.
Continued ...

Jan 9, 2013 7:14 am 3 Photos
Region home sales: Best year since 2007

The upswing in sales and housing values that is fueling Coldwell Banker Schmidt Realtors' investment in renovation is reflected in 2012 sales numbers just released by the Traverse Area Association of Realtors.
Continued ...

Jan 9, 2013 7:14 am
Grand Traverse's emergency coordinator retires

Grand Traverse County's emergency management coordinator is retiring from his post after more than 30 years as a county employee.
Continued ...

Jan 9, 2013 7:14 am 1 Photo

Click here for more Region stories

Life


Tours give local connection to seeing world

TRAVERSE CITY - Martha Ryan loves to travel, but annual trips to places like Tuscany and Salzburg, Budapest and Prague could be beyond her means.
Continued ...

1 Photo
Cheerleader for literacy, reading and children1 Photo
Loraine Anderson: The real face of America1 Photo
Fleda Brown: Thoughts give way to poems1 Photo
Ed Hungness: Quiet hour during vacation?1 Photo

Click here for more Life stories
Sports


True student-athlete

When Mike O'Brien graduates from Glen Lake this spring, he'll do so with 12 varsity letters. Four apiece in football, basketball and golf. It's been a long and illustrious career for O'Brien, but his mark on the school goes well beyond the playing fields.
Continued ...

1 Photo
Competitors get warm day for 5-mile race1 Photo
Traverse City Central falls to top team1 Photo
Lutz nets hat trick against Traverse City West1 Photo
Traverse City Central's Ryan to walk on at MSU1 Photo

Click here for more Sports stories
Business
Business briefs: 01/13/2013

Continued ...


Business memoranda: 01/13/2013
Cost and pricing: Skills pay dividends
Downtown certificates set sales record for 20122 Photos
Ag Forum: Deer damage is increasing1 Photo

Click here for more Business stories


Unlimited access to Record-Eagle.com

Top Jobs


Top Autos


Top Recreational


Top Stuff


Top Real Estate


Top Rentals


WILLIAMSBURG. 1BR lower of house. Large, bright, clean. $575 + util. 231-883-6000. ...more »

WEST SIDE. 21/2 miles out Cherry Bend. 2BR, W/D, appl. Huge garage. $800/mo. 231-499-6650 ...more »

Orlando, Florida 5 min from Disney. 2 weeks at Vacation Village. Feb 9 th -Feb 23 rd . ...more »

2BR, 2 BA condo, downtown TC. Yearly lease. No pets/smoking. $1,050/mo 231-944-6273. ...more »

BONITA BEACH/NAPLES FL.area. Monthly or seasonal rental. Completely remodeled & ...more »

2BR, 1BA, apt, Bass Lake, $600/mo includes utils. No smoking/dogs. 231-463-6832 ...more »

CENTRAL Neighborhood, 4BR, 2BA. Lease, ref. req. No smoking/pets. $1,500/mo. 709-1714. ...more »

 


Source: http://record-eagle.com/loc...

JAN 11 2013
https://www.windaction.org/posts/35862-elmwood-turbine-may-be-near-end-of-life
back to top