Articles filed under Legal from Oklahoma

Florida Based Energy Company Violates New Law

Ok-agletter-nextera-violation_thumb The actions of a Florida-based energy company are proving to be a test case for a new law intended to protect what many believe is Oklahoma's most valuable military asset -- air space. A News 9 investigation reveals the company, NextEra Energy, is putting up new wind turbines without the needed federal approval, in violation of a recently approved state law.
31 Aug 2018

Tenth Circuit takes expansive view of the definition of the term “mining,” holding wind farm project needs permit prior to commencement of excavation in tribal mineral estate

United States of America v. Osage Wind, LLC et al., 871 F.3d 1078 2017 WL 4109940 (10th Cir. Sept. 18, 2017). Causing heartburn for project applicants developing on tribal land, the Tenth Circuit reversed the District Court for the Northern District of Oklahoma’s grant of summary judgment and determined that the defendants’ large-scale excavation project, involving site modification and the use of excavated rock and soil in the installation of wind turbines, constituted “mining” under federal regulations addressing mineral development on Native American land. Id. at *1. This decision creates new obligations for developers, which could result in delay and additional costs.
1 Mar 2018

10th Circuit Court declines to rehear Wind Farm case

In a unanimous decision issued in mid-September, a three-judge panel reversed and remanded a September 2015 summary judgment from the Northern District Court of Oklahoma that allowed Osage Wind to conduct excavation work in order to set up 84 wind turbines across 8,400 acres without a mining permit from the Bureau of Indian Affairs or approval from the Osage Minerals Council.
18 Oct 2017

Osage Nation wins wind farm fight

The Denver Federal Appeals court, in a unanimous decision overturned a lower court ruling and said Enel Green, the owner of Osage Wind, had to obtain a mining permit in the construction of its wind farm in western Osage County, land controlled by the Osage Nation.
27 Sep 2017

NextEra wants wind farm dispute out of federal hands

Attorney Kimberlee Spady represents the plaintiffs and alleged in her petition that NextEra filed the forms, but did not include the latitude and longitude of each turbine or specify the distance from the nearest airport, among other things. The public notices published in The Hinton Record also didn’t include information required by state law, Spady wrote.
16 Mar 2017

Nation awaits 10th Circuit Court ruling in Wind Farm case

Acting on behalf of the Osage Minerals Council, the United States brought the litigation forward in 2014, contending that the company was appraised of that requirement but ignored it anyway and at one point, sped up construction in an effort to finish its work before a federal court could issue a ruling.
11 Oct 2016

Osage Nation seeks to intervene in wind lawsuit

The tribe’s Minerals Council has argued that the pits, measuring as much as 60 feet wide and 30 feet deep, amount to “mining” and violate the tribe’s mineral rights, which includes ownership of rocks and minerals below the surface. The Osage Wind development west of Pawhuska has destroyed more than 60,000 cubic yards of minerals, according to the lawsuit.
2 Dec 2015

Cell Tower Court Ruling Could Affect Wind Farms in Oklahoma

A State Appeals court recently upheld a lower court ruling that the telecommunications tower built on property near Ken Laubenstein’s home was a nuisance. ...But now some are wondering how the ruling might impact the state’s growing wind farms and possibly a lawsuit filed by landowners in Canadian and Kingfisher Counties against Apex Clean Energy Inc.
22 Oct 2015

http://www.windaction.org/posts?location=Oklahoma&topic=Legal&type=Article
back to top