Article

Injunction sought over alleged wind turbine threat to eagles, other protected species in Upper Peninsula

Garden Peninsula Foundation in January filed a lawsuit against Traverse City-based Heritage Sustainable Energy LLC and U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. The group is seeking damages for loss of quality of life and asked that the project be re-evaluated or abandoned.

DELTA COUNTY, MI - An Upper Peninsula group has filed for an injunction to stop construction of power-generating wind turbines on Lake Michigan's northern shore that it says pose a risk to endangered species of migrating birds.

Garden Peninsula Foundation in January filed a lawsuit against Traverse City-based Heritage Sustainable Energy LLC and U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. The group is seeking damages for loss of quality of life and asked that the project be re-evaluated or abandoned.

Garden Peninsula Foundation filed for a temporary injunction to halt any construction while the lawsuit proceeds through U.S. District Court in Marquette.

"... (T)he expansion of Defendant's proposed wind turbine project will result in the 'taking' of federal protected specials, the Kirtland's warbler and Piping plover, because (a) construction will impair habitat and (b) construction, erection, and operation of the wind turbines will kill and/or injure Kirtland's warbler and Piping plover who live, forage, migrate and mate on or in close proximity to the current proposed site of the wind turbines," attorneys Susan Hlywa Topp and Michelle Halley wrote in the request for an injunction.... more [truncated due to possible copyright]  

DELTA COUNTY, MI - An Upper Peninsula group has filed for an injunction to stop construction of power-generating wind turbines on Lake Michigan's northern shore that it says pose a risk to endangered species of migrating birds.

Garden Peninsula Foundation in January filed a lawsuit against Traverse City-based Heritage Sustainable Energy LLC and U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. The group is seeking damages for loss of quality of life and asked that the project be re-evaluated or abandoned.

Garden Peninsula Foundation filed for a temporary injunction to halt any construction while the lawsuit proceeds through U.S. District Court in Marquette.

"... (T)he expansion of Defendant's proposed wind turbine project will result in the 'taking' of federal protected specials, the Kirtland's warbler and Piping plover, because (a) construction will impair habitat and (b) construction, erection, and operation of the wind turbines will kill and/or injure Kirtland's warbler and Piping plover who live, forage, migrate and mate on or in close proximity to the current proposed site of the wind turbines," attorneys Susan Hlywa Topp and Michelle Halley wrote in the request for an injunction.

The attorneys wrote that "the projects would 'take' Bald and Gold eagles in violation of the Bald and Gold Eagle Protection Act."

Garden Peninsula maintains that Heritage intends to construct 21 turbines this year.

"The Garden Peninsula in Delta County, Michigan, is home to generations of farmers and is a rural and picturesque community on the shores of Lake Michigan. It is also a well-known migratory bird haven in a crucial migratory pathway and is used for nesting, foraging and migration by numerous birds including Kirtland's warbler, Piping plover, Bald and Gold eagles and other endangered, threatened, or protected species," the group's attorneys wrote.

Heritage Sustainable Energy contends that seven years of pre-construction and post-construction studies and monitoring showed that Heritage Garden Wind Farm had "minimal impact to birds ... ."

The wind farm became operational in September 2012, with 14 2-megawatt wind turbines.

"Predictions made by anti-wind groups of massive bird fatalities at the HGWF are proven to be completely inaccurate," the company said on its website.

"The entire HGWF causes fewer bird fatalities in a year than a single house cat."

A study showed the wind farm has had no significant impact on any of the bird species during the first two years of operation, the company said. The turbines pose "only a very minor and insignificant threat" to bald eagles.

Heritage Garden Wind Farm generates enough power to supply nearly half the households in Delta County, the company says.

The lawsuit says the Fish and Wildlife Service strongly disagreed with an expert for Heritage over his assessment of avian risk, and said it "is likely to pose a very high risk for avian mortalities, including a high risk for bald eagle mortalities," the lawsuit said.

John Agar covers crime for MLive/Grand Rapids Press E-mail John Agar: jagar@mlive.com and follow him on Twitter at twitter.com/ReporterJAgar

 
Real Estate
FOR RENT
Ypsilanti, MI

FOR RENT
Detroit, MI

 

 

Reddit
Related Stories

Morning Review: Injunction sought over alleged wind turbine threat to eagles, other protected species in Upper Peninsula

Upper Peninsula wind turbines will kill eagles, other protected species, lawsuit says
 
8 comments
Sign in
 
 
Post comment as...
Newest | Oldest
Whoozeonfirst
Whoozeonfirst 12 hours ago
http://www.rechargenews.com/wind/1387234/Buffetts-PacifiCorp-fined-2.5m-for-bird-deaths-at-Wyoming-wind-farms

FlagShareLikeReply
grjohn
grjohn 15 hours ago
We do not need these things. Lets set up oil rigs on Lake Michigan and DRILL BABY DRILL!

FlagShareLikeReply
watchcaltwp
watchcaltwp 15 hours ago
To be successful in their attempt to ban them they need a Kennedy or Kerry to buy some land up there.

FlagShare1BigDaddyWambaLikeReply
BigDaddyWamba
BigDaddyWamba 12 hours ago
@watchcaltwp  NIMBY Royalty...

FlagShareLikeReply
ZRtst
ZRtst 17 hours ago
I love it when liberals fight each other.

FlagShare3UofM1976Concerned CitizenanonymousLikeReply
GRman
GRman 17 hours ago
Wind turbines - kills the occasional bird - nothing like coating them in oil! / Sarcasm

FlagShare2I am not a crookhoneLikeReply
aktow
aktow 17 hours ago
Good. Don't let anyone install these things. They are god-awful to look at and can hardly be considered environmental.

FlagShare1ZRtstLikeReply
hone
hone 17 hours ago
@aktow

Wrong.


FlagShare2UofM1976SueLikeReply
 


Academic State Champs: Michigan's Top 25 schools

Schools ranked individually for first time
Where does your school rank?
See Top 25 school districts
View all coverage »
Most Read


Powerball numbers for March 14, 2015; one ticket matches $137 million jackpot

Train hit, killed pedestrian who police said appeared to have deliberately gone in front of it

Michigan's 2014-15 season ends with being passed over by NIT

Jim Harbaugh focused on separating best from the rest at Michigan, no matter what

Projecting how an extension might work for new Detroit Lions DT Haloti Ngata

Get a free cone at Dairy Queen in celebration of 75th anniversary
Get the latest updates

Subscribe to our newsletters
Like MLive on Facebook
Follow MLive on Twitter
Active Discussions

1Aramark worker ordered prisoner to feed inmates at Michigan prison cake partially eaten by rodents
(284 comments)
2Ann Arbor school board considers weapons-free school policy
(730 comments)
3Live chat: Come talk NCAA tournament bracket picks with MLive writer Brendan F. Quinn at 11 a.m.
(40 comments)
4What's best for kids? Michigan adoption bills would protect faith-based agencies, limit LGBT options
(46 comments)
5Did Gov. Snyder violate the Michigan Constitution with executive order? Expert says no
(108 comments)
See more comments »
Best of MLive.com  


Source: http://www.mlive.com/news/g...

MAR 17 2015
http://www.windaction.org/posts/42363-injunction-sought-over-alleged-wind-turbine-threat-to-eagles-other-protected-species-in-upper-peninsula
back to top